I’m Majoring in Science, With a Minor in Wishful Thinking

The infiltration of pseudoscience in academia, either universities proper or academic health centres, is very real. Dr. David Gorski is doing a great job reporting on the American side of this disturbing inroad, but I thought it was time to tackle the Canadian (and more specifically the Quebec) perspective.

The Prince Arthur Herald recently published an article of mine entitled “I’m Majoring in Science, With a Minor in Wishful Thinking”. You may be surprised to learn that chiropractic, reflexology, and acupuncture have all made forays into academia in Montreal.

From the article,

“What used to be a shibboleth—a phrase such as “evidence-based”—is now commonly used by quackademics as a smokescreen to deceive funding agencies, the general public, and perhaps the quackademics themselves. Everyone is engaging in “evidence-based practice”. The phrase has stopped to carry the meaning it once had and now serves as a fashion rule. If you don’t put “evidence-based” in front of what you practice or research, you will not be taken seriously. The critical assessment of the evidence that used to follow is no longer a requirement.”

You can read the full article here.

I would also encourage you to post it on social media and to comment on it. My last article for the Herald elicited a number of irrational comments from the hardcore believers in the power of sugar pills. Let’s hear it for rationality.

Are We Alone? Lorne #Trottier Symposium Next Week!

Symposium Poster

 

The question being asked may be “Are We Alone?”, but I don’t think I will be alone Monday and Tuesday night, attending an all-new edition of the Lorne Trottier Public Science Symposium. Dr. Joe Schwarcz hosts a two-night event on the subject of life in the universe, with four qualified speakers: Jim Bell, Jill Tarter, Sarah Seager, and Joe Nickell.

I hope to see you there!

For more information on the symposium, click here!


Read: The Food Babe’s Friends… and Critics

If you listen to my podcast, Within Reason, you know my thoughts on Vani Hari’s crusade against ingredients whose  names she can’t pronounce. On her blog, FoodBabe.com, she regularly commits logical fallacies in her attempt to “educate” the public on what constitutes healthy food.

Kathleen Purvis of the Charlotte Observer recently wrote a fairly lengthy article addressing the Food Babe phenomenon. Its author gets quotes from people on both sides of the debate, which might strike one as a fallacious “equal balance” approach but which I found nonethless interesting. Our very own Dr. Joe Schwarcz is among the Food Babe critics who get to express their opinion:

“”Whatever the story is with azodicarbonamide has nothing to do with whether it’s a yoga mat chemical,’ Schwarcz says. ‘This is absurdity, to say if something is used in one context, it can’t be used in food.

‘We use water to wash our cars. Vinegar can be used to kill weeds. If she ever found out, she’d want salad dressing banned.'”

I would encourage you not only to read the full article but to send it to some of your more impressionable friends.
My favorite sentence from the article?
“Although appendicitis is not often linked to nutrition, she decided hers was caused by inflammation she blamed on her diet.”
And that is why claims made by Vani Hari are often spurious, ridiculous, and sometimes even dangerous: they come from wishful thinking, not rational investigations.
The full article can be accessed here.
If you want to hear Dr. Schwarcz speak at length on this issue and don’t mind apparent irreverence on the subject, check out episode 106 of Within Reason (also available on iTunes)!

Are We Alone in the Universe? Find Out in October!

The Lorne Trottier Public Science Symposium returns to Montreal on October 6 and 7.

“Are We Alone? Searching for Life Out There” is this year’s theme, and the guests are:

  • Dr. Jill Tarter, SETI Institute;
  • Dr. Jim Bell, President of the Planetary Society;
  • Dr. Sara Seager, MIT;
  • Dr. Joe Nickell, Senior Research Fellow at CSICOP.

You can check out the poster, which was just released a day ago, by clicking here.

My thoughts on last year’s symposium can be accessed here.

See you there!


From Twitter: On Being Insulting

Screen Shot 2014-07-01 at 9.24.21 PM

Screen Shot 2014-07-01 at 9.24.31 PM

Screen Shot 2014-07-01 at 9.24.51 PM

 

To listen to the episode in question, head over here and download episode 106.


Read: Scientific Journal Nature Chemistry Finally Publishes List of Chemical-Free Products

Via @edyong209 on Twitter, here is some good news for people like The Food Babe.

Prestigious scientific journal Nature Chemistry has published a fantastic paper by A.F.G. Goldberg and C.J. Chemjobber entitled “A comprehensive overview of chemical-free consumer products”.

I invite all of you to have a look at it. It’s a short read.

If you’re still worried about chemicals in our environment after reading this groundbreaking paper, I would encourage you to listen to my conversation with Dr. Joe Schwarcz on chemophobia.